The short answer
Track new patients each month from the practice system, with the source each one gave at intake. Divide total marketing spend by that count to get cost per new patient.
Next, count the enquiries that lead there: calls, appointment requests, and online bookings, by source. Then keep a short list of checks inside each channel you run.
Compare each month with the same month last year, and end every review with one decision.
Three levels of numbers
Every marketing tool reports dozens of numbers. A KPI is one that ties to a decision. Sort them into three levels and read them in order.
-
Level 1
Outcome
New patients and what each one cost. This is what the practice owner decides on.
-
Level 2
Enquiries
Calls, appointment requests, and bookings. They show whether marketing is reaching people who want an appointment.
-
Level 3
Channel checks
Numbers inside each platform. They explain why levels 1 and 2 moved, and where to look first.
If level 1 is steady, a dip at level 3 rarely needs action. If level 1 drops, work down: did enquiries drop, and if so, in which channel?
New patients and their cost
The new patient count comes from the practice management system, not from an ad platform. Ads and Analytics count clicks, calls, and forms. Only the practice knows who became a patient.
Ask every new patient how they found you, and keep the answer list short: search, map listing, ad, friend or family, insurance list, mailer, other. Count the answers by source each month.
Two formulas
Cost per new patient = all marketing spend for the month ÷ new patients that month.
Enquiries that became patients = new patients ÷ (calls + appointment requests + bookings).
Include agency fees and software in spend, not only ad costs. Cost per new patient by channel only works when spend and the intake answer use the same source names. The CPA guide covers the Google Ads side.
Calls, requests, and bookings
In Google Analytics, mark the events that matter as key events: the appointment request form and, if you have one, the online booking. Reports such as Traffic acquisition then show key events by source. Google Ads can use the same key events as conversions, so both tools count the same thing.
Calls need their own count. Call tracking numbers can report calls by source. Without them, a simple front desk log of new patient calls and how each caller found you still works.
Keep patient details out of all of it. Google's Analytics policies say no data Google could use to identify a person, such as a name, email address, or phone number, should be sent in URLs, events, or campaign tags. The GA4 calls, forms, and bookings guide shows the setup.
Channel checks
Keep two to four checks per channel. They explain a change at level 1 or 2.
Google Ads
Cost, conversions, and cost per conversion. Search impression share is the share of impressions your ads got out of those they could have got, and it shows whether more budget or a higher bid could reach more people.
Read the search terms report too, and add negative keywords for searches you do not want.
Business Profile
The performance report shows calls, website clicks, and direction requests from the profile. Tag the profile's website link with utm values, so those visits show up under the profile in Analytics.
Website
Engagement rate is the share of sessions that lasted longer than 10 seconds, had a key event, or had two or more page views. Bounce rate is the opposite.
For speed, web.dev's Core Web Vitals targets are LCP within 2.5 seconds, INP of 200 milliseconds or less, and CLS of 0.1 or less, at the 75th percentile of page loads.
Social and email
Spend, and the key events that came from each one. Use the same utm_source and utm_medium values every time, so Analytics can group the visits.
Quality Score is worth a look when a keyword costs more than you expect. Google rates it from 1 to 10 for each keyword, from expected clickthrough rate, ad relevance, and landing page experience. Google also says it is a diagnostic tool, not a KPI.
KPI sheet builder
Pick the channels you run and how you count calls. The builder lists the columns for a monthly KPI sheet and where each number comes from. Copy the header row into a spreadsheet and fill one row a month.
The form starts with a sample practice that runs Google Ads, a Business Profile, and organic search, and uses call tracking.
A monthly review
Set aside half an hour after the month closes. Fill the sheet, then answer three questions.
- 1 Did new patients go up or down against the same month last year, and from which sources?
- 2 Did enquiries move the same way? If not, look at how calls are answered and how requests are followed up.
- 3 Which channel check explains the change, and what is the one thing to change next month?
Write the decision in the sheet's notes column. After a year, the sheet shows your own seasonal pattern, which is a better guide than any average.
Numbers to keep out of the headline
Followers and likes
They show reach. Track the visits and requests that come from social instead.
Quality Score
Google calls it a diagnostic tool, not a KPI, and says it is not an input in the ad auction.
Total website visits
Visits rise and fall with things that do not bring patients. Read requests and calls next to them.
A single ranking
Results differ by searcher and place. Read clicks and enquiries from search instead.
Industry averages
Another practice's cost per patient is not a target for yours. Compare with your own last year.
Checklist
KPI checklist
0 of 12 done
Related guides
Setting up the events is in conversion tracking for a practice website. Reading the Analytics screens is in how to read your Google Analytics dashboard.
Practices with several offices can use the per-office marketing report and the shared and office marketing costs guide.
For your practice
DDS Web Solutions builds websites and runs search, ads, and reporting for dental practices. Our team has been building websites since 2014, we have served 100+ practices, and our offices are in Sacramento and San Mateo. We can set up call tracking and reporting in SmileTrak, key events in Google Analytics, and a monthly KPI sheet that starts with new patients. We do not promise calls or new patients. See dashboards and reporting or request a quote.
FAQ
What is the single most useful marketing number for a practice?
New patients for the month, counted in the practice system, with the source each patient gave at intake. Cost per new patient comes next. Every other number explains why those two moved.
How do I work out patient lifetime value?
Use your own records. Take a group of patients who started at least a few years ago, add up what they have spent since, and divide by the number of patients. Use that figure to judge how much you can spend to win a new patient. Industry averages are not a substitute.
Is a high bounce rate bad?
In Google Analytics, bounce rate is the share of sessions that were not engaged. A session is engaged if it lasts longer than 10 seconds, has a key event, or has two or more page views. A visitor who reads an office's hours and calls may still count as a bounce, so read it next to calls and requests.
Which Google Ads numbers should I check each month?
Cost, conversions from primary actions, cost per conversion, and search impression share. Impression share shows whether more budget or a higher bid could show your ads more often. Read the search terms report as well, so spend goes to searches you want.
How often should I change marketing based on these numbers?
Look at Google Ads search terms weekly, the KPI sheet monthly, and the channel mix once a quarter. Many practices see seasonal swings, so compare a month with the same month last year before you cut or add budget.
What changes for a practice with several offices?
Add an office column and fill one row per office each month. Shared costs, such as the website and a brand campaign, need a written split rule before you compare cost per new patient across offices.
Sources
- Google Analytics Help: About key events
- Google Analytics Help: Engagement rate and bounce rate
- Google Analytics Help: Best practices to avoid sending personally identifiable information
- Google Analytics Help: Collect campaign data with custom URLs
- Google Ads Help: About impression share
- Google Ads Help: About Quality Score for Search campaigns
- Google Ads Help: About the search terms report
- Google Ads Help: Primary and secondary conversion actions
- Google Business Profile Help: Understand your Business Profile performance and insights
- web.dev: Web Vitals